What To Ask Before Hiring An AI SEO Company

Run the Baseline Properly Run each prompt in a signed out session, or in a fresh session with memory and personalisation disabled. Your own browsing history and past conversations will otherwise skew results toward showing you what you already know.

This is the pattern search followed, and there is no obvious reason for it to play out differently here. The advantage of early movement is not that the channel is large yet, it is that the positions are cheap.

One argument tends to close the internal debate faster than any of the above. The audit produces a prompt set, and the prompt set is reusable by anyone you hire afterwards. It converts a vague brief into a specific one, which improves every proposal you receive and lets you compare suppliers on the same evidence rather than on the confidence of their pitch.

Be wary of pricing tied to a proprietary visibility score, since the vendor controls both the number and the prompt set that produces it. Be equally wary of performance pricing tied to mentions, which sounds aligned and creates pressure to game the measurement rather than improve the business.

Set Up So You Do Not Fool Yourself Open a signed out session, or a fresh one with memory and personalisation disabled. This matters more than anything else in the method. An account that has spent the week researching your own company will show you a flattering picture that has nothing to do with what a stranger sees.

Legacy Content Is an Asset and a Liability An older site carries accumulated mentions, which is genuine value that a new domain does not have. It also carries accumulated inconsistency: superseded pages, old contact details and descriptions that no longer match what the organisation does.

Crawler access restored on a date. Listings claimed and corrected, with a count. Factual errors fixed on third party sources, with a count. Pages published that answer prompts your baseline showed were being answered badly. Reviews responded to.

Ask What They Will Not Do Good practitioners have a list. They will not guarantee a position in an answer, because nobody controls that. They will not fabricate reviews or seed forum threads under false identities, because it is detectable, damaging and increasingly enforced against.

Ask Who Writes and Who Reviews Find out whether the writing is done by somebody with subject knowledge or generated and lightly edited. Both happen, and the second is not automatically disqualifying, but you need to know because you are the one who carries the liability for inaccurate claims about your own products.

Read the Source List Before the Prose Where citations are shown, list every domain and count how often each appears. This is the single most useful output of the whole exercise, and most people skip it because the prose is more interesting.

Keep a record of what you predicted as well as what you measured. Writing down at the start of a quarter what you expect to move, and then reading it back at the end, is the cheapest way to find out whether your model of this channel is any good. Most teams never do it, which is why the same confident explanations survive for years without ever being tested.

You can do this yourself in about half an hour, with no subscriptions and no technical knowledge. It will not be as thorough as a full engagement, and it is more than enough to establish whether you have a problem and roughly what kind.

Present but described wrongly means a source problem, and the source list tells you which page to correct. Present and accurate on definitional prompts but absent on the who should I hire prompts means your category presence is fine and your commercial positioning is not corroborated anywhere independent.

The Cheapest Fixes Have a Deadline That Already Passed Audits routinely surface mechanical problems that have been quietly costing visibility for months. Crawlers blocked in robots.txt. A bot management product returning challenges to legitimate retrieval agents. Key content rendering only after JavaScript executes. Specifications trapped in a PDF.

It does not contain a return on investment figure calculated from an assumed conversion rate applied to an estimated mention volume. That calculation looks rigorous and is a chain of guesses, and it will not survive the first person who asks where the first number came from.

What Transfers to an Ordinary Business Three things, and they are the three that most small operators skip. Check that you are readable before assuming you have a content problem, since on a small site an access failure is total rather than partial.

Absence is not disqualifying on its own, since their category is crowded and they may serve a niche. But they should have an interesting answer, and the answer should not be defensive. A practitioner who has run this test on themselves will have thought about it and will tell you what they found.

This is a working method you can run yourself in an afternoon, repeat monthly, and hand to an agency as a brief. It produces a record you can argue with, which is more than most reporting in this field manages. llm visibility tracking